Subscribe via RSS Feed

Are Catholic Bishops Living Too Lavishly? CNN Says So

August 14, AD2014 15 Comments

Over the weekend, I came across an article that stopped me in my tracks. The CNN Belief blog lists the residences of many of America’s prominent Catholic bishops, noting their size and value, which they define as “lavish.” It made me think about the morality of how a bishop should live.

Recently, Pope Francis, who is known for his humble ways, warned seminarians and nuns to avoid the temptation of thinking “the latest smartphone, the fastest moped and a car that turns heads” will make them happy. He even recommended riding a bike, or if you have to drive a car, to just “get a humbler one.”

But because this CNN article was not from the Catholic Church, rather from secular media, I knew there had to be more than meets the eye, so I asked some lay folks, priests, well-known Catholic personalities and Catholic authors to weigh in along with my thoughts.

Don’t Judge a Book by Its Cover

Patti Armstrong, a prominent Catholic writer and author, noted that while the article pointed out the size and value of these residences, it did not consider how the bishops live in these residences. It is quite likely that they live humbly within the walls.

“People are judging by the building,” she said. “No one has been able to point to opulent living. You can’t judge by the cover and a house is just a cover.” She notes that St. Thomas Moore was a martyr whose position with King Henry VIII afforded him luxurious living. “The residence that comes with a position does not indicate necessarily how one lives,” she said.

Additionally, these residences are not the bishops’ personal homes but rather belong to the diocese.

A Matter of History

There is also the issue of the importance and magnificence of some of these buildings. Just as the Vatican holds a treasury of incredible artwork, written works, gorgeous historic cathedrals and ancient “lavish” artifacts, so may some of these American cathedrals and structures be historically or architecturally significant – now or down the line.

“Imagine if all of the Vatican treasures had been sold off, all that history,” said Armstrong. “There would be nothing for us to see today.” In caring for these buildings, opening them for public use and appreciation, and passing them down from bishop to bishop from priest to priest and from parish to parish, the Church is being a good steward of precious possessions. After all, if we are judging things by size and value, the size of St. Peter’s is several football fields and contains priceless works of art and no one thinks that should be sold!

Teresa Tomeo, host of Catholic Connection on EWTN radio and popular Catholic author, noted, “A lot of these homes have been in the various dioceses for decades or even longer and are attached or very close to the cathedrals.” A great article over at CatholicVote.com also notes that many of these residences were built over a century ago so the church is not paying mortgages. They also write that many of the buildings written about in the article are in some of the largest metropolitan areas with the highest property values.

But what about the newer homes built specifically for these bishops? “Many have been donated or built by the people and most are used as places for other clergy to stay when they come to town,” said Tomeo.

Meeting the World Where It Is

The need for meeting space and accommodations for overnight guests is another reason for the size of some of these residences. Many may house several priests or even staff in addition to the bishop. The argument can also be made that bishops must entertain prominent individuals who might not be accustomed to such humble surroundings as dictated by the Catholic Church. While that may be the case, would anyone, even royalty, have demanded that Mother Teresa meet them in a more lush space?

Father Christopher Roberts of the Lafayette, Ind., diocese and blogger at For Christ and the Church also noted that “The Church has always tried to engage the world in order to convert it,” and that, in fact, Peter and Paul went to Rome for that reason. “Sharing the Gospel in the modern world will often mean the Church has to adopt modern business practices and technology.” But the question is, to what extent?

What Does the Church Teach About This?

In the Catechism of the Catholic Church, it says “The precept of detachment from riches is obligatory for entrance into the Kingdom of Heaven. All Christ’s faithful are to ‘direct their affections rightly lest they be hindered in their pursuit of perfect charity by the use of worldly things and by an adherence to riches which is contrary to the spirit of evangelical poverty.’” (2544-2545)

Thanks to Father Roberts for directing me also to the PRESBYTERORUM ORDINIS document from Vatican II. It echoes Father’s sentiments about working in the world when it says, “Their ministry itself, by a special title, forbids that they be conformed to this world; (20) yet at the same time it requires that they live in this world among men. (21)” Vatican II, Presbyterorum Ordinis, Chapter I, No. 3, 20-21

Here is more from this document that directs us on the morality of a priest’s and bishop’s use of “goods”:

Ecclesiastical goods, properly so called, according to their nature and ecclesiastical law, should be administered by priests with the help of capable laymen as far as possible and should always be employed for those purposes in the pursuit of which it is licit for the Church to possess temporal goods-namely, for the carrying out of divine worship, for the procuring of honest sustenance for the clergy, and for the exercise of the works of the holy apostolate or works of charity, especially in behalf of the needy.(45) Those goods which priests and bishops receive for the exercise of their ecclesiastical office should be used for adequate support and the fulfillment of their office and status, excepting those governed by particular laws.(46) That which is in excess they should be willing to set aside for the good of the Church or for works of charity. Thus they are not to seek ecclesiastical office or the benefits of it for the increase of their own family wealth.(47) Therefore, in no way placing their heart in treasures,(48) they should avoid all greediness and carefully abstain from every appearance of business. – Vatican II, Presbyterorum Ordinis, Chapter III, Section 2, No.17, 45-48

And:

A certain common use of goods, similar to the common possession of goods in the history of the primitive Church, (52) furnishes an excellent means of pastoral charity . . . Before the other followers of Christ, let priests set aside every appearance of vanity in their possessions. Let them arrange their homes so that they might not appear unapproachable to anyone, lest anyone, even the most humble, fear to visit them. – Vatican II, Presbyterorum Ordinis, Chapter III, Section 2, No. 17, 52 & 53

Here’s what stands out to me:

  • All excess should be set aside for the good of the Church or works of charity.
  • They should avoid all greediness.
  • They should carefully abstain from every appearance of business.
  • Let them arrange their homes so that they might not appear unapproachable to anyone.

Not Size, but Intention

I think we need to view this from the perspective of not how big is the rectory and how much is it worth, but how are the bishops “addressing their affections,” or in other words, what is their intention in having these large, valuable properties? Where is their heart?

If their intentions are to serve Christ and they believe this is the most effective means of doing so, then they are following His directive and living out His Word. If they are being tempted into luxury and greed or attracted to worldly things to maintain such properties and they could carry out their tasks without these items, they are not.

But this is next to impossible for an outsider, especially secular media, to know, and we can be certain we will be judged by the same measure with which we judge others. Who among us is not attached to worldly goods?

What Can We Learn from This?

One important lesson I see is remembering that the Church is not perfect, as it’s made up of imperfect humans – priests, bishops, lay people, nuns, monks, deacons – in a fallen world and has done wrong in the past, as have we all. It does not hurt to take a close look at what the Church is doing to look for ways to improve.

This is an area, in my humble opinion, where I believe the Church can probably do better. I’m sure there are many cases where maintaining a more valuable, large rectory is warranted and the most efficient means of pastoring a flock, but I’m also sure there are cases where it is not.

Let’s all challenge ourselves as followers of Jesus, with our bishops, to more closely follow the narrow path to which Christ has called us and look at the intentions of our hearts when it comes to worldly goods. Where it’s possible, let’s downsize and give, not just out of our abundance, but out of our need like the widow. Jesus told the rich man – and the apostles – to give away everything and follow Him. The Church is not perfect, but it can strive to be, as Jesus calls us, and in following Pope Francis’ lead.

As Father Roberts said, “I admire Cardinal Sean O’Malley’s decision to live at the Cathedral Rectory in Boston. I hope more bishops, priests and lay people follow his lead.” Me, too.

Note: I reached out to the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops to see if they had an official response to this CNN article.  They did respond, saying they did not.

Filed in: Art, History

About the Author:

Lyn was a 30+ year nonbeliever who never dreamed she’d be Catholic and passionately so! She is a wife and mother of two school-age boys, as well as a cat and a dog, and lives in the lovely little village of Zionsville near Indianapolis. Lyn is a Butler Bulldog, and for her day job, she runs her own public relations and blog writing business, Step Ahead Inc. A longtime writer, she's worked in journalism and public relations for many years. Lyn came to Catholicism in 2011 after being married to a nonpracticing Catholic for 10+ years. She never had a shred of interest — and in fact was averse to it — until she began to feel a faint desire to go to the local Catholic church. It only grew from there! Visit Lyn's site A Catholic Newbie.

If you enjoyed this essay, subscribe below to receive a daily digest of all our essays.

Thank you for supporting us!

  • Patti Maguire Armstrong

    Thanks Lyn for revealing the hypocrisy of such attacks. Like the Pharisees, they make outside appearances more important than a holy life, criticizing the building and ignoring the lives being lived within.

    • Lyn Mettler

      Thanks Patti and thanks for sharing your wise insight :)

  • Elijah fan

    Not so fast…you’re whole essay is ok only if these mansions are occasionally hosting the poor yet even then it takes some sophistry to align them with this passage from Vatican II:

    DECREE ON THE MINISTRY AND LIFE OF PRIESTS
    PRESBYTERORUM ORDINIS
    PROMULGATED BY HIS HOLINESS,
    POPE PAUL VI
    ON DECEMBER 7, 1965
    ” Led by the Spirit of the Lord, who anointed the Savior and sent him to evangelize the poor,(53) priests, therefore, and also BISHOPS, should avoid everything which in any way could turn the poor away. Before the other followers of Christ, let priests set aside every appearance of vanity in their possessions. Let them arrange their HOMES so that they might not appear UNAPPROACHABLE to anyone, lest anyone, even the most humble, fear to visit them.”

    Here by the way is Isaiah 5:8 which the Newark case is literally questionable on:
    ” Woe to you who add house to house and join field to field till no space is left and you live alone in the land.”

    The Newark double mansion with two pools is so far from Newark and its poor and on 8.5 suburban acres that the poor can’t afford the gas to look for it. It’s for a working retirement in which he will be hosting rich donors….when he’s not facing the existential dilemna of which pool to use….or which of many fireplaces he need light.

    Do I host the poor? I did for quite some time as judgement day will prove. And separately one came through my front window two years ago uninvited but martial arts is a weekly hobby and he cried uncle out on the sidewalk.

    • asmondius

      The archdiocese owns the property, and has always cared for the poor.

      Taking a dip in the pool will not cure hunger or homelessness.

    • Elijah fan

      I continue to recommend you into a career in haiku.

  • http://healingandempowerment.blogspot.com Phil Dzialo

    Ah! Palaces for the “princes of the church”? Why is it that every time someone questions the status of clericalism of the RCC they are compared to hypocrites, Pharisees, etc.

    Here is a simple statement as I am acutely aware of Cardinal Sean O’Malley’s room at the Cathedal Residence in Boston, his car and his simple clothes and the fact he lives next to one of the poorest abysmal housing projects in Boston.

    As long as there is one homeless person, one hungry person, one institutionalized person who should be housed elsewhere, one unaccompanied minor fleeing Central American death, one abjectly poor person….all the wealth of the Church, no matter how historic, artful or beautiful, all the mansions, the art, the gold, the glittter of vestments and rods and staffs, etc……this is OBSCENE. It is not the way Christ lived nor the way he directed others to live.

    Matt 19:21 “Jesus answered, “If you want to be perfect, go, sell your possessions and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me.” Is this not clear….not only for the RCC but for ALL who profess to be Christian.

    As for the comment about “lives lived within.” Give me a break…household help, fine food and drink, luxury cars, chauffeurs,,,,,also, visit the five star dining establishments in Rome and guess who dines there.

    These media attacks are not attacks…only if you react defensively. They are obscene abuses which is why Pope Francis choose his simple lifestyle, lives in a hotel and eats in a cafeteria…no Prada shoes and confronts the Cardinal of Bling. Let’s stop being defensive and follow Christ’s directive which is very straightforward. As Benedict 16 always said, the enemies of the Church are within the Church, not outside the institution.

    • asmondius

      You don’t like the Catholic Church – we get it.

      The Pope doesn’t live in a ‘hotel’, by the way.

    • http://healingandempowerment.blogspot.com Phil Dzialo

      You are right the Pope lives in the Vatican guesthouse not a technical hotel….it’s not an issue with Christianity, it’s the way it’s lived through the clericalism of the “princes”…

    • asmondius

      The Church has an ecclesiastical hierarchy – is that what you are objecting to?

    • http://healingandempowerment.blogspot.com Phil Dzialo

      I object to clericalism….

    • Micha Elyi

      I object to clericalism….

      –Phil Dzialo

      So you say.

      CNN didn’t raise any issue of “clericalism”.

      Why is it that every time someone questions the status of clericalism of the RCC they are compared to hypocrites, Pharisees, etc.

      Your question assumes a falsehood.

      Matt 19:21

      If you knew what the Bible recorded in Matt 19:21, you’d know that Jesus was addressing one specific person, not imposing a rule upon all his disciples.

      By the way, if you really thought Matt 19:21 teaches what you claim it does you’d have no computer and no time for your quibbling on the Internet.

      Finally, you’ll notice that I have not called you out as a hypocrite. Maybe you’re just unaware.

    • asmondius

      Which is….?

    • Manny Perez

      Cardinal O’Malley belongs to the Capuchin Order. Members of his order take a vow of poverty and minister to the poor. When a Capuchin is ordained a bishop (as he was in 1992) he is released from his vow of poverty. However, the Cardinal has chosen to continue to live simply and continues to wear his brown Franciscan habit with sandals.

  • David Peters

    Lyn this is an excellent article. Before I even began reading it I thought of these houses being in expensive cities, and that they may be old. I really enjoyed the way you addressed the physical buildings and the heart attitude of those in leadership. Although I don’t know any bishops, I have found Catholic leaders in general very humble and approachable. And I love Pope Francis and his Spirit-led leadership! I am very blessed by the Catholic Church.

    • Lyn Mettler

      Thanks David!