Subscribe via RSS Feed

Marriage is Not a Fairy Tale

March 26, AD2014 18 Comments

\"LeticiaI read this piece by Simcha Fisher that was a response to this piece by Emma Smith on Catholic Exchange. I thought I would add my piece. I feel like I have a different point of view than both Simcha Fisher and Emma Smith, but I agree with Simcha when she says that marriage is “a tangled ball of good intentions and bad habits, unhealed wounds and unfounded desires.” These words should be written on the top of every single sheet of paper handed to a couple preparing for marriage, in or out of the Catholic Church.

My life experience includes having a child out of wedlock at seventeen, being in an invalid marriage with a drug addict and being married in the Church to the love of my life, thinking that God would protect me from ever being hurt by my husband simply because we were in a valid Catholic marriage. Having been where I\’ve been, I think that the root problem is that many people think that marriage is an escape from the hurts of the world. I don’t really know if it comes from the fairy tales or romantic movies, but I do know that in a society like ours that is creating wounded human beings because of divorce and broken homes, and people just want relief. Relief from pain, being unloved, the heartache that comes with living in a broken home and a loss of sense of self.

We are generations deep in the broken home norm, and these generations are also the furthest away from any kind of faith. They are the “nones” as people like to say. They don’t believe in God and they have no religious affiliation. Yet they are the ones in the most pain. They are left looking for love. Their parents didn\’t do it and they have no clue who God is so they can’t have faith in Him to do it.  They are left wandering the world looking for that one person who will love them, validate them, and keep them safe. And that is a huge mistake.

The common thing that I see among believers and unbelievers is the need to avoid pain. It’s what motivates people. “Happiness” is the carrot that is hung in front of us and the way to get “happiness” is to avoid pain. That is the trick of the devil. The only way to happiness is through pain, it is through resurrection, after the worst pain that life really begins. That belief is the center of our faith. That includes our life, our conversions, our marriages, our bodies, our relationship with Jesus, our friendships and everything else. Nothing can become holy without pain, death and resurrection. The more we avoid that fact the more we reject a Christ who was crucified, died, was buried and rose from the dead. That is our Christian faith.

It goes for marriage too. Catholics cannot go into a marriage thinking that there will be no pain. We are human, we sin, it’s how we roll. Then we have to reconcile ourselves to God through confession and mercy, and in marriage there has to be those same elements.

I am thirty-seven years old. I was thirty-four years old, divorced, been around the block and had four children on my wedding day and I thought that God would protect me from being hurt by my husband because of the grace of the Sacrament. I was wrong. I have hurt my husband deeply and he has hurt me. In fact, this marriage has caused me (and my husband) more pain that any other relationship ever has.

However, there is a grace in the Sacrament of Marriage that you can do nothing to earn. Sometimes that grace is the only thing you have when you are sitting in front of the tabernacle telling Jesus how much you wish you had never heard of Him because this whole Christian thing sucks and marriage is the worst part of it all.

It is grace that helps you get past the pain and get to marriage counseling. It is grace that helps you see the human being in your spouse and realize that his wounds are why he has let you down and not because you are not worthy of love. It is grace that helps you realize that God is faithful and His Love is where you go for the safety, security and the promise of not being let down. Your spouse isn\’t God. Your spouse can not carry the weight that is intended to be carried by God. It’s that simple. Anytime you put that kind of expectation on a finite human being, you will be disappointed.

Sometimes in marriage, the forgiveness has to come without a confession. The priest who prepared my husband and me for marriage told us all of this when we were engaged and we weren\’t prepared to listen. It all came back to me the day that I cried myself to sleep thinking that marriage was the worst mistake I had ever made. Somehow, a miracle I am sure, God heard my cries and my husband and I sat down and talked things out without anger, threats or insults. We began going to marriage counseling and for the first time in about a year we discussed what was really going on with us both. It is by the grace of God  that I can sit here and not feel like my heart has been torn apart because of things that my husband has said to me in anger and vice versa. I have hurt him and he has hurt me. And it will happen again, because we are sinners tied to each other by a bond that means I can’t kill him or walk away in the middle of the night. It is not a fairy tale, it is reality.

St. Joseph pray for us.

About the Author:

Leticia is a convert who came into the Catholic Church at Easter 2010. She is the mother of 4 kids. She is homeschooling her youngest child, has two in Jr High and her oldest is grown up and about to have a child of his own this summer. Leticia is on her Pastoral Council, blogs at Catholic Sistas as well as her personal blog, is a full-time student, a wife, and helps with her parish's Jesus is Lord adult faith formation class and RCIA. In her spare time she sleeps.

If you enjoyed this essay, subscribe below to receive a daily digest of all our essays.

Thank you for supporting us!

  • WHB

    Your experience is that of a ‘saint in the making’ That is the way of humanity. Without deprivation that comes through evil we can never understand the beauty of God’s Grace and the Good from Him for us all, if we have the courage to accept it. You are a brave and wonderful young sinner. I am an old, sometimes brave sinner. We all have to keep up the fight and always remember this mantra: No Faith, No Hope, No Future. In marriage, in raising a family, in seeking peace and regeneration of our souls. Thanks for your wonderful post.

  • RyanKraeger

    I think this article is better than either of the two that came before it, though for the life of me I cannot see why there should be any kind of debate between the two. I look back at some of the things I wrote when I was younger by even five years, and I cringe. I look at some of the things teenage friends write and I cringe. But I don’t see the sense in debating them. They will learn, soon enough, just as I did. Just as I will. (To be clear, I am not referring to Simcha Fisher or Emma Smith per se, but mostly to the plethora of commenters.)

    At any rate, If I may believe my engagement experience, nothing brings out issues you never knew you had like seriously considering marriage, except, it seems, for actually being married!

  • John Darrouzet

    Just got around to reading these exchanges. Here’s what I posted as a comment on Simcha’s post.

    “Simcha, Simcha, Simcha. As Pope Francis might say: “There’s a sourpuss in your mirror.” Do you see it?”

    • Rose Nigel

      John – Simcha’s a sourpuss for giving a naive and self-satisfied girl a much-needed reality check? I think that’s exactly the opposite of what Pope Francis is talking about.

    • http://thebodyguardtob.wordpress.com/ Jim Russell

      Well, about that “reality check”–Emma Smith’s take on marital fidelity is not a product of being naïve or self-satisfied, in my view, but rather is a result of her quite-real and accurate understanding of what the Church teaches about marital fidelity. Mutual fidelity is one of the essential things a couple is supposed to know is “real” when exchanging consent to the lifelong mutual fidelity of marriage, obviously–if it’s something you’re not sure of, then how can it be something you’re really sure you’re consenting to?

    • John Darrouzet

      Right on, write on.

  • David Peters

    Leticia, this article has a tremendous amount of insight. You’re right we do try to avoid pain, and that is not how we grow. Thank you for being open enough to share some of your pain and being honest about it. I learned from reading it. God bless you and your marriage!

  • gilbert

    Leticia, I hace been reading several comments on Facebook where Abby is involved. I can honestly say that your in the right frame of mind. I think that it has to do with our Christian faith and through what glasses are we perceiving marriage. If we see it with Catholic glasses then you will be understood. Remember we believe in redempting suffering. Let’s us not forgot the story of saint Monica. +JMJ+

  • Pingback: The Anglican Ordinariates & A New Ecumenism - BigPulpit.com

  • Micha Elyi

    Miss Emma Smith may never have heard the Spanish proverb, “If you want to hear God laugh, tell Him your plans.”

  • john654

    Leticia, I think, you will understand this when I say, “Marriage is a Martyrdom”. I’ll share one of the most joy filled moments of my life with you. I have been married 34 years. It wasn’t until I finally got eye contact with my wife and told her that she was finally free to love me, I told her she was number TWO in my life. It was then that we started to find joy in our marriage! Jesus is number one! That’s when I picked up my cross and really began to love my wife! NOTE: I was corrected by a few of the Fathers of Mercy, I work there. We are not sinners, (we have faults), we are “REPENTANT” sinners and there is a HUGE difference! Love your husband, tell him he is number TWO!

  • Pingback: Divorce Gets the Goop Treatment

  • Pingback: Suffering Comes Like a Walker

  • http://hector1088.blogspot.com/ Dave Heath

    Thank you for this…as a victim of an wanted and unsolicited divorce and annulment, and still Faithful to my vows and the Mother of my children, I have told my kids – all teens and older – many of the same things you relate here, almost word for word. After four years, I believe I have made some small advancement in the understanding of some that are still estranged from me and who still hold that all the marital woes are mine to own. You have given validity to the Truth – the Catholic Truth – to my counsels to them to the contrary and supported this Father in catechizing his kids, Enough so that I have sent them emails and copied your article for their hopeful edification.

    God Bless!

  • Pingback: 7 QTs Blog Battles, Marriage, Writers and Termite Swarms | Crazy Face

  • James

    Leticia, beautiful words as usual. Thank you.
    <3

  • Pingback: Pastoral Sharings: " Fourth Sunday of Lent" | St. John

  • Pingback: Marriage is Beautiful, Painful and Real | Crazy Face